Foreign troops offer Haiti temporary fix, but security reforms needed, report finds
Published in News & Features
The arrival of more robust international forces could help Haitian authorities drive back powerful armed gangs. But the deployment of a United Nations-authorized Gang Suppression Force and thousands of Salvadoran soldiers will not produce lasting security unless Haiti fixes its internal security apparatus, according to a new report by the International Crisis Group.
“The new foreign mission promises temporary relief from the bane of gangs,” the report said. “But its goal is to weaken, not dismantle them. Haiti should start preparing now for the day when its own forces are once again summoned to take sole charge of the nation’s security.”
The report, released Tuesday, is based on approximately 110 interviews conducted between March and November 2026. It examines Haiti’s increasingly crowded security landscape, in which a patchwork of domestic forces is in charge of fighting deadly gangs amid overlapping operations, weak coordination and accountability concerns.
Its release coincides with a warning from the United Nations human rights office that gangs continue to perpetrate atrocious abuses against the population, while Haitians also continue to find themselves at risk from intensified security operations when they are not conducted in full compliance with international human rights law.
At least 4,595 people have been killed and 2,050 injured as a result of armed violence as of Oct. 31, according to Marta Hurtado, spokesperson for the U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights. In the same quarter, at least 340 women and girls were subjected to sexual violence — the vast majority of whom were victims of gang rape. This brings the total number of cases of sexual violence to 1,497 during the time period.
Hurtado stressed that while gangs continue to perpetrate abuses against the population, Haitians are also dying as a result of security operations.
At least 514 people were killed and 235 injured during security operations conducted by national security forces against gangs between July and September — at times with the support of the private military company, the U.N. said during a meeting in Geneva on Tuesday. Another 44 people were reported killed in extrajudicial killings by police officers outside anti-gang operations.
“As security operations intensify, gangs have adapted their tactics,” Hurtado said. “These include retaliatory attacks against residents suspected of cooperating with security forces, targeted and organized kidnappings, increased forced recruitment of children and young people, and tighter restrictions on people’s freedom of movement, all aimed at deterring security operations.”
The International Crisis Group, an independent organization that studies conflicts around the world, warns that the proliferation of national security forces as well as the presence of a series of international military deployments may not bring a lasting reduction in violence.
The report notes that the Gang Suppression Force has approximately 2,000 personnel deployed in Haiti, with plans to expand to 5,500 by early 2027. Meanwhile, El Salvador President Nayib Bukele has dispatched about 2,500 soldiers, the vast majority of whom are operating outside the command structure of the GSF. There is uneven coordination among the groups, the report notes.
In early November, Prime Minister Alix Didier Fils-Aimé established a Joint Information Center to coordinate the various forces. But Haiti still lacks an overarching security strategy, the report said, with some operations driven more by foreign governments or private contractors rather than Haitian authorities.
“Regardless of how successful the GSF or the Salvadorans may be in thwarting the gangs, lasting improvements will depend on whether Haitian security forces can eventually assume prime responsibility for public safety,” the report said.
The Haiti National Police, the country’s lead security force, remains deeply weakened by political interference, corruption rackets and a lack of experience in community policing, the Crisis Group said, while calling for reforms.
The challenges persist even as the government, with support from the United States, aims to add at least 4,000 officers within 18 months. More than 3,000 recruits have already joined the force, the report said, but the accelerated training program has raised concerns about whether the new officers are adequately prepared.
Training has been reduced from seven months to less than four, with greater emphasis on combat.
“A senior police officer, for example, noted that recruits learn little about law enforcement standards, including the proportionate use of force,” the report said. A former member of the force noted that Haiti’s combat-centered approach measures success primarily by the number of people killed or injured, whereas in other countries such results are viewed as a sign of unprofessional police practices.”
The report also looks at the controversial role of the separate security task force operating out of the prime minister’s office. It is staffed mostly by foreign contractors associated with Erik Prince, the former Navy SEAL and founder of Blackwater, the task force working with police and operating explosive drones and helicopters.
While the drone strikes appear to have helped to put gangs on the defensive as Haitians focus on regaining territory, Crisis Group said the strikes “have killed dozens of bystanders, while the task force has failed to meet key tactical objectives such as reasserting state control over national roads.”
“Haitians have little clarity as to the command and control of this force, which has only recently begun coordinating more closely with the police,” said the report, which recommends strict rules governing drone strikes and greater transparency about foreign contractors’ responsibilities.
The report also recommends that foreign private security contractors should be gradually phased out once the GSF can sustain operations against the gangs.
U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk has called on all national and international security forces operating in Haiti, whether under the Gang Suppression Force or outside its framework, to ensure their operations fully comply with international human rights law, and that they prioritize protecting the population.
Under those standards, any use of force by law enforcement officials, including those acting on behalf of the state, must strictly limit the use of lethal force to situations where it is unavoidable to protect life from an imminent threat, and as a last resort — and even then, to act in a proportionate fashion.
The U.N. human rights chief also urged the Haitian authorities to strengthen effective oversight over the security forces, investigate alleged violations — including extrajudicial executions — and ensure accountability.
“Our Office continues to support Haitian authorities in addressing the impact of security operations on the population,” Hurtado said. “So far this year, U.N. human rights officers have trained more than 1,300 police officers involved in anti-gang operations on human rights norms and standards.
“We have also supported the Gang Suppression Force in delivering human rights training to newly deployed contingents in Haiti,” she added.
The high commissioner also reiterated his call to the international community to promptly and fully deploy the Gang Suppression Force to help counter the spiraling gang violence in Haiti, in strict compliance with international human rights standards and norms. He also called on the international community to not only impose sanctions on gang leaders themselves, but to also focus on those controlling criminal networks and benefiting from them.
“States need to act urgently and decisively to crack down on the continuous illicit flow of weapons and ammunition into Haiti, in line with Security Council arms embargo,” said Hurtado. “Authorities also need to prioritize strengthening the rule of law and the justice system to end impunity. More robust efforts must also be made to fight deepening corruption, inequality and poverty.”
Haiti’s other security forces
Crisis Group also looks at efforts to rebuild Haiti’s armed forces and bring the Protected Areas Surveillance Brigade, BSAP, into the anti-gang fight.
Although President Jovenel Moïse officially reinstated the armed forces in 2017, and they have gradually expanded, Crisis Group questions whether investing heavily in a military force is the best use of Haiti’s limited resources. The group warns that the army could compete with the police for funding and contribute to the militarization of domestic law enforcement.
Decisions about rebuilding the army should not be driven primarily by its potential to fight armed gangs, the report said.
“Although the armed forces can help maintain control over some areas retaken from armed groups, involving them in urban operations could set a dangerous precedent and blur the distinction between the police and the military,” the report said.
Crisis Group also raised concerns about the environmental brigade, BSAP, which today is operating largely beyond government control. Some of its members have been accused of drug trafficking, arms smuggling, kidnapping, extortion and involvement in armed political activities. The brigade’s ties to political figures and its deployment on behalf of a particular political force also make bringing it under state control challenging, the report said.
Port-au-Prince would do well to rein in the Protected Areas Surveillance Brigade, which seems to be operating far beyond its original mandate of providing security in environmentally sensitive areas, the report said.
“After assessing the number of personnel required to cover the country’s protected areas, authorities should confine the brigade to operating in those regions, limit the type of weapons its members are authorized to carry, and establish robust oversight mechanisms to ensure that its officers focus exclusively on preventing environmental crimes,” the report said.
Among the recommendations, the Crisis Group urges Haitian authorities to establish a functioning National Security Council to coordinate domestic and international forces and develop a long-term security strategy. It also recommends mapping out a path to professionalize Haiti’s security forces, including improving working conditions, and creating clear, merit-based paths toward promotion.
“Officers need vetting, and each force requires stronger, independent controls and oversight,” the report said. “Clear boundaries should also be set on the deployment of drones and other lethal weapons.”
______
©2026 Miami Herald. Visit at miamiherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments